Do Smart Thermostats Save Money?

Yes, smart thermostats can save money when they reduce heating and cooling you would otherwise use unnecessarily. However, savings depend on your existing habits, equipment, climate, and how you configure the thermostat.

If you already follow an efficient schedule with a compatible programmable thermostat, upgrading may provide more convenience than additional savings.

Before buying, compare the complete installed cost with a realistic estimate of the benefit. Compatibility matters just as much as the features advertised on the box.

How Can a Smart Thermostat Reduce Costs?

A smart thermostat controls when and how your heating and cooling equipment operates. It does not make a furnace or air conditioner inherently more efficient.

Depending on the model, useful features may include:

  • Schedules you can adjust through an app.
  • Remote changes when your plans change.
  • Occupancy detection or location-based settings.
  • Learning features that suggest or adjust schedules.
  • Compatible heat-pump recovery controls.
  • Usage reports and maintenance reminders.

Not every model includes every feature. A feature saves energy only when it changes operation in a useful way.

For example, remote access could help you avoid maintaining your usual occupied settings during an unexpected trip. It could also increase consumption if you regularly use it to heat or cool more than before.

How Much Money Could You Save?

ENERGY STAR’s smart-thermostat FAQ cites average savings of approximately 8% of heating and cooling bills, or about $50 annually. That is a general benchmark, not a personalized forecast or a guarantee.

It also refers to heating and cooling costs—not an automatic 8% reduction in your entire utility bill.

Your result may differ because of:

  • Your current thermostat schedule.
  • How often your home is occupied.
  • Local weather and energy prices.
  • The equipment and controls you have.
  • How much you override automated settings.
  • The compatibility and quality of installation.

If your heating and cooling costs are low, even a meaningful percentage reduction may represent a modest dollar amount.

Read the ENERGY STAR smart-thermostat FAQ for context.

Smart vs. Programmable vs. Manual Thermostats

Type Main function What to consider
Manual You change the setting yourself. Useful changes depend on remembering to make them.
Programmable Follows a schedule you set. May already handle a predictable routine effectively.
Smart Adds connected controls and model-specific automation. Can make adjustments easier, but added features do not guarantee added savings.

A smart model is not automatically the cheapest solution. Correcting the schedule on a thermostat you already own may provide much of the benefit you need.

The best choice is a compatible control you can use correctly and comfortably.

Check Compatibility Before Comparing Prices

Identify your equipment and use the manufacturer’s compatibility tools before purchasing.

Check:

  • Whether the system uses low-voltage, line-voltage, or proprietary controls.
  • Heating and cooling equipment types.
  • The number of heating and cooling stages.
  • Heat-pump auxiliary or backup heat requirements.
  • Zoning and any communicating system features.
  • Power and wiring requirements.

Some thermostats require a common wire, often called a C-wire, or a manufacturer-approved power accessory. The correct solution depends on the thermostat and system.

Do not assume wire colors establish compatibility or that an adapter suits every installation.

Electric baseboards and some ductless or communicating systems need different controls from a conventional low-voltage furnace and air conditioner.

Ask a qualified installer when compatibility is unclear. An unsuitable thermostat can remove useful equipment functions or cause operating problems.

Heat Pumps Need Appropriate Controls

Some heat pumps use electric resistance heat as backup. Large heating setbacks can trigger that backup during recovery, reducing the savings you expected.

A compatible thermostat may offer recovery features designed to limit unnecessary auxiliary heat. Those features still need appropriate configuration for the equipment.

Before using an aggressive away schedule, ask:

  • How does this system recover from a setback?
  • When does auxiliary heat operate?
  • Does the thermostat support the required stages and controls?
  • What schedule does the manufacturer or installer recommend?

Do not disable necessary backup heat simply to reduce its recorded usage.

The Pacific Northwest National Laboratory thermostat-controls guide explains heat-pump recovery considerations.

Calculate the Full Upfront Cost

Include more than the thermostat’s shelf price.

Your total may include:

  • The thermostat.
  • Professional installation.
  • Required wiring or compatible accessories.
  • Applicable taxes.
  • Optional sensors you intend to use.
  • Any ongoing charges for features you want.

Subtract only rebates or discounts you have confirmed apply to the exact model and installation.

If your current thermostat needs replacing anyway, compare the additional cost of the smart model with another suitable replacement. That is different from replacing a working control solely for potential savings.

Example: Estimate the Payback Period

A simple calculation can help screen the purchase:

Simple payback = net upfront cost ÷ estimated annual savings.

Consider these hypothetical figures:

Item Illustrative amount
Thermostat $150
Installation $100
Confirmed rebate −$50
Net upfront cost $200

If annual savings were $50, simple payback would be four years.

At $25 annually, it would take eight years. At $100 annually, it would take two years.

These are examples, not product quotes or predicted savings. The calculation excludes financing, ongoing fees, changing energy prices, and the value of convenience.

Use several savings assumptions rather than treating an optimistic estimate as certain.

When an Upgrade May Be Worth Considering

A smart thermostat may offer useful value when:

  • Your home follows an inefficient heating or cooling schedule.
  • Your routine changes and remote adjustments would help.
  • You frequently forget to adjust a manual control.
  • You need a replacement and the additional cost is reasonable.
  • The model is compatible and its features fit your needs.

You may also value remote access or alerts independently of energy savings. That is a valid preference, but keep it separate from the financial calculation.

When Keeping Your Current Thermostat May Make Sense

An upgrade may provide limited financial benefit if:

  • Your existing schedule already suits your household.
  • Your home requires fairly consistent conditions.
  • You would disable the features expected to produce savings.
  • Installation requires costly changes.
  • The new control would sacrifice important system functions.

Before buying, try correcting your current schedule and reviewing available settings.

Our guide to saving money on heating and cooling covers maintenance and other changes that do not require a smart thermostat.

What a Smart Thermostat Cannot Fix

A new thermostat cannot repair leaking ducts, replace missing insulation, correct every airflow problem, or restore failing equipment.

It also does not automatically create separate heating and cooling zones.

A remote room sensor can help a compatible thermostat decide which temperature readings to prioritize. It does not necessarily let the system independently heat or cool that room.

Do not close vents throughout the home as a substitute for a properly designed zoning system.

If rooms remain uncomfortable or bills rise unexpectedly, investigate the underlying cause before assuming a new controller will solve it.

Review Wi-Fi, Privacy, and Utility Programs

Check which functions require internet access, an account, or a cloud service.

Ask what happens during a Wi-Fi outage and whether schedules and local controls continue working. Features and long-term support vary by model.

Review permissions before enabling location-based automation or connecting other smart-home services.

If a utility offers a rebate or an enrollment incentive, check whether it involves a demand-response program. Understand any temporary temperature adjustments, override options, participation requirements, and incentive conditions before enrolling.

Use current program terms rather than assuming a rebate is available everywhere.

Set It Up Around Real Conditions

After installation, review the schedule instead of relying entirely on default settings.

  • Account for people working from home or following different schedules.
  • Keep settings appropriate for health, comfort, pets, humidity, and the building.
  • Follow system-specific guidance on setbacks and recovery.
  • Review any learning or occupancy changes.
  • Update settings when the season or household routine changes.

Maintenance reminders are useful prompts, but they do not replace manufacturer instructions or confirm that equipment is working properly.

How to Check Whether It Is Helping

Keep notes on the installation date and any major settings changes.

Review utility consumption over comparable periods, accounting for billing days, weather, occupancy, and energy-rate changes.

Thermostat runtime reports can show patterns, but runtime is not always a direct measure of energy cost. Multistage and variable-speed equipment can use different amounts of energy while running.

A lower bill after installation does not prove the thermostat caused the entire difference. Likewise, a higher bill during unusually severe weather does not automatically mean it failed to help.

See How to Lower Your Electric Bill for help separating consumption from other charges.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do smart thermostats save everyone money?

No. Results depend on your starting routine, equipment, settings, and conditions. Some households mainly gain convenience.

Can a programmable thermostat provide similar savings?

It can provide useful scheduling benefits when compatible and correctly programmed. Smart features may make adjustments easier, but their additional value varies.

Can I install a smart thermostat myself?

Only if the installation is suitable for your skills and permitted under applicable requirements. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions. Use a qualified professional if you are unsure about wiring, voltage, or system configuration.

Will a smart thermostat work with electric baseboards?

Only if the exact model is designed and rated for that system. Many common smart thermostats are intended for different equipment.

Can renters install one?

Ask the landlord or property manager before changing installed controls. Confirm compatibility, permission, and responsibility for installation and future maintenance.

Check the Schedule Before Replacing the Thermostat

A smart thermostat can help when its controls reduce unnecessary heating and cooling. It is less likely to deliver substantial additional savings when your existing routine is already efficient.

Start with compatibility, calculate the complete cost, and decide which features you will use. Then compare realistic savings with the price rather than buying on a percentage claim alone.

Explore our Home & Housing section or Is It Worth It? for more cost comparisons.

Sources and Further Reading

Scroll to Top